Spotting
 Timeline
 Travel Tip
 Trip
 Race
 Social
 Greeting
 Poll
 Img
 PNR
 Pic
 Blog
 News
 Conf TL
 RF Club
 Convention
 Monitor
 Topic
 #
 Rating
 Correct
 Wrong
 Stamp
 PNR Ref
 PNR Req
 Blank PNRs
 HJ
 Vote
 Pred
 @
 FM Alert
 FM Approval
 Pvt

RailCal - Train Search + Time-Tables + Avl Calendar + Forum

Ballari Jn - Look around and enjoy the station. A sacred place where Mahatma Gandhi once spent 8 hours. - Vishwanath Joshi

Search Forum
<<prev entry    next entry>>
Blog Entry# 2173805
Posted: Feb 22 2017 (08:05)

10 Responses
Last Response: Mar 22 2017 (20:33)
1 Followers
General Travel
4007 views
10

Feb 22 2017 (08:05)  
TejasS~
TejasS~   8592 blog posts
Entry# 2173805               Past Edits
1 compliments
Hope they will materialize our idea
Guys, the ministry has asked people for concrete, workable suggestions and ideas thru this website of theirs click here under 6 broadly classified important aspects of the Indian Railways. While the invitation is open for all citizens from all walks of life, I just thought as railfans, we are better placed to offer what is asked for. Its a small gesture to give back something to an institution that we so dearly love and which has brought us all together on this platform here. Honestly speaking, I have my own doubts if our ideas would ever materialize having a fair knowledge of how our govt organizations typically works but we can surely claim to be on a high pedestal and claim to have done our 'duty'/ bit to the cause and put the ball in their court. More importantly we can discuss, debate and fine-tune all those suggestions...
more...
here on IRI after or before our submissions there.
PS. The registration and submission processes appear to be slightly cumbersome like any other sarkaari website, but hardly takes a couple of mins.
This is the link-
click here

Translate to English
Translate to Hindi
Show AI Response

7 Posts

1406 views
0

Feb 22 2017 (16:35)
SingleTraveller^~
SingleTraveller^~   3245 blog posts
Re# 2173805-8              
@2173805-3  @guest
What kind of growth?
Translate to English
Translate to Hindi
Show AI Response

1669 views
1

Feb 22 2017 (16:48)
TejasS~
TejasS~   8592 blog posts
Re# 2173805-9               Past Edits
Suggestions or innovative ideas in this particular case do not come under the ambit of railfanning or RF hobbies. As railfans, we're simply better placed and are more 'superior' to make those suggestions than normal citizens. Dont think a slight nudge here and there would alter equations anywhere. A RF offering ideas is no way superior to a RF doing photography or videography, but a small exhortation to RFs pointing out to them that more can be done for apart from photography and videography or making TTs is nothing wrong IMO.
Translate to English
Translate to Hindi
Show AI Response

1079 views
0

Mar 22 2017 (19:14)guest
Re# 2173805-10              
there is a trust deficit that exits between the RF community & the IR Machinery, there is always a fear factor while rail-fanning at stations... the RF community needs to bridge this trust deficit through such initiatives....
.
and "growing up" here doesnt mean leveling up from something inferior, when you grow from infant to child you dont become superior from inferior... i am only highlighting the need to shoulder additional responsibility for the RF community beyond photos & videos.
Translate to English
Translate to Hindi
Show AI Response

972 views
0

Mar 22 2017 (19:15)guest
Re# 2173805-11              
i have explained it the post above
Translate to English
Translate to Hindi
Show AI Response

1068 views
0

Mar 22 2017 (20:33)
SingleTraveller^~
SingleTraveller^~   3245 blog posts
Re# 2173805-12              
@2173805-10  @guest
But do you think the govt. (this or any other) really bothers to improve IR from such initiatives? There have been numerous committees who have given suggestions for improvement. The IR employees themselves, who know the mess inside-out, have given suggestions. When govt. never bothers to listen and implement them, You think fans like us will be respected or heard? All these are publicity gimmicks similar to sending baby food to people who tweet or free wifi, to grab headlines and showcase the govt. as a innovative one taking feedbacks from people.
-
Trust
...
more...
deficit? The simple reality is railfans are mocked at. Personally I have experienced IR employees who have mocked me when I was young and asked a few innocuous questions. They don't understand what railfanning and passion for trains is . This post sums it up /blog/post/2143581.
-
An article I read in IRI news - An article on railfans who go to any lengths like climbing mountains to take pics and having good knowledge about locos. The newspaper reported it and also quoted rail officials saying that these fans are passionate, but sometimes behave as though they know better than us which is dangerous. Not trust deficit, just plain disdain....
-
My take is govt. has no use for any suggestions, just for publicity they will implement some small idea of some IIT guy and tom-tom it as a "Green initiative" or "Make in India" or "Digital India" vision. They are masters at conning the public with PR blitz.
-
There are so many members who have tweeted or complained through various forums and there has been no reply, let alone suggestion being acted upon. Here is the latest one /blog/post/2205270.
-
All members on this forum - who have so many suggestions, ideas, discussions and creating imaginary trains - are all part of innovative thinking as to what can be done to improve IR. A dream, hope, yearning ..... that if these ideas are acted upon, then IR will improve. But reality is its just confined to this forum, because all know, even if we all were to consolidate and send these ideas and suggestions, nothing will come of it...... Will be thrown out by 'powers that be' or just will gather dust as many expert committee reports are gathering dust.
-
P.S.: I personally do see the discussions here on the forum by all members as something beyond photos and videos /blog/post/2173805
-

Translate to English
Translate to Hindi
Show AI Response
Scroll to Top
Scroll to Bottom
Go to Desktop site
Important Note: This website NEVER solicits for Money or Donations. Please beware of anyone requesting/demanding money on behalf of IRI. Thanks.
Disclaimer: This website has NO affiliation with the Government-run site of Indian Railways. This site does NOT claim 100% accuracy of fast-changing Rail Information. YOU are responsible for independently confirming the validity of information through other sources.
India Rail Info Privacy Policy