Spotting
 Timeline
 Travel Tip
 Trip
 Race
 Social
 Greeting
 Poll
 Img
 PNR
 Pic
 Blog
 News
 Conf TL
 RF Club
 Convention
 Monitor
 Topic
 #
 Rating
 Correct
 Wrong
 Stamp
 PNR Ref
 PNR Req
 Blank PNRs
 HJ
 Vote
 Pred
 @
 FM Alert
 FM Approval
 Pvt

RailCal app

site support

तमन्ना जहाज के सफर की... क्यों करूं मैं, दिन भर की खुशियाँ लम्हों मे बर्बाद क्यों करूं मैं। - Amir

Search Forum
<<prev entry    next entry>>
Blog Entry# 3234424
Posted: Mar 24 2018 (19:15)

6 Responses
Last Response: Mar 25 2018 (11:26)
General Travel
2139 views
3

Mar 24 2018 (19:15)  
Rajas RAO~
Rajas RAO~   233 blog posts
Entry# 3234424               Past Edits
INDIAN RAILWAYS TO STOP INTRODUCING MAIL/SF AS NEW TRAINS?
These days, there seems to be a trend that IR prefers to introduce only humsafars/ac exp as new trains, and there seems to be very few new trains introduced as express/sf trains. So does this mean IR will stop introducing conventional express trains altogether? I decided to do some fact checking analysis:
-I looked for new introduced trains between 1/10/2017 to today (24/3/2018) using IRI trains list. I compared no. of mail/exp/sf trains introduced vs. no. of 'luxury' trains. My definitions of luxury train
...
more...
include AC exp, AC SF exp, HS trains, Tejas exp, Shatabdi and Rajdhani exp.
-For the sake of comparison, I didnt consider suvidha trains/tatkal spl, AC specials, pass/ fast pass trains, international trains, MEMU/DEMUs, and trains that were diverted or extended, Trains introduced with RSA are considered as single train.
-I found following things:
- Following new exp/SF/JS/antyodaya trains were intoduced in last ~6 months:
1. 19807/8 Kota JP exp
2. 14717/8 BKN Haridwar exp
3. 15611/2 GHY Silchar exp
4. 17245/6 DMM Machilipatnam exp
5. 22151/2 PUNE KZJ SF exp
6. 22987/8 AII Agra fort SF exp
7. 15564/5 Udhna Jaynagar antyodaya
8. 15125/6 PNBE Kashi Jan Shat. exp
- Comparing to no. of luxury trains introduced in last 6 months:
1. 20817/8 BBS-NDLS Rajdhani
2. 20501/2 Agartala-ANVT Rajdhani
3. 19667/8 Palace queen humsafar
4. 02412/3 Arunachal AC SF exp
5. 20601/2 MAS Madurai AC SF exp
-So this show that IR is still introducing conventional exp. But we can also see that nearly ask these trains are due to popular demand, not as election tactic/gimmick. But if we look at luxury train list, 2 of these trains, (Agartala RAJ and MYS UDZ HS) are introduced during election time.
- And about 40% new trains introduced in last 6 months are AC only luxury trains. As far as I know, this is much higher than the rate IR used to introduce rajdhanis/shatabdis in 90's or during 2000's. So we can definitely say that IR is introducing more and more AC trains.
-This is not very surpirsing in my opinion bcoz IR said somectime ago that only 3ac segment is very profitable for IR. So this move seems logical if IR wants to stay in business mainly due to stiff competition from cheap airlines. But does that mean sacrificing demands of people who can't affort ac travel??
request everyone to provide opinion/comments.
(All data taken from IRI train search).

Translate to English
Translate to Hindi

1 Posts

938 views
0

Mar 24 2018 (19:26)
Rajas RAO~   233 blog posts
Re# 3234424-2              
In that case IR has introduced more luxury trains than new ones, which means there is clear trend, but it needs to be seen if this is sustainable for IR, coz majority of pass. earnings still comes from non-ac if I'm not wrong
Translate to English
Translate to Hindi

888 views
0

Mar 24 2018 (19:27)
Reva18~
Reva18~   56837 blog posts
Re# 3234424-3              
Earnings come from 3A class only. All other classes are not earning any revenue for IR.
Translate to English
Translate to Hindi

898 views
1

Mar 24 2018 (19:31)guest
Re# 3234424-4               Past Edits
Non AC class is loss making....
Even if sleeper is 130-150% full it just covers the operating cost
3AC gives profit even if just 80% full
Dynamic 3AC is profitable even on 60% patronage
In
...
more...
future more and more AC coaches will be added..

Translate to English
Translate to Hindi

790 views
1

Mar 24 2018 (21:21)
Ben_Kenobi~
Ben_Kenobi~   4222 blog posts
Re# 3234424-5              
nobody understands what exactly IR is upto
their business plan is helping drive many people away from railways owing to low speeds and high costs
once UDAN scheme becomes operational and many airports in tier-2 and tier-3 cities start operating the monoply that IR had in those areas will be gone, and along with that will be the high paying passengers.
they won't, atleast
...
more...
in short term stop introducing train for such a move would backfire badly on them politically, but yes, mostly only hum sab suffer and asuvidha are being introduced.

Translate to English
Translate to Hindi

646 views
0

Mar 25 2018 (11:26)
Irshad13~
Irshad13~   8101 blog posts
Re# 3234424-6              
IR should start good mail/Exp & SF trains also where as these Premium trains will be costly to travel for Middle class & poor ppl often. Their should be proper balance too between both of the services as rail services can be used by all poor ppl with afforadble costs..
Translate to English
Translate to Hindi
Scroll to Top
Scroll to Bottom
Go to Desktop site
Important Note: This website NEVER solicits for Money or Donations. Please beware of anyone requesting/demanding money on behalf of IRI. Thanks.
Disclaimer: This website has NO affiliation with the Government-run site of Indian Railways. This site does NOT claim 100% accuracy of fast-changing Rail Information. YOU are responsible for independently confirming the validity of information through other sources.
India Rail Info Privacy Policy