Spotting
 Timeline
 Travel Tip
 Trip
 Race
 Social
 Greeting
 Poll
 Img
 PNR
 Pic
 Blog
 News
 Conf TL
 RF Club
 Convention
 Monitor
 Topic
 #
 Rating
 Correct
 Wrong
 Stamp
 PNR Ref
 PNR Req
 Blank PNRs
 HJ
 Vote
 Pred
 @
 FM Alert
 FM Approval
 Pvt

RailCal app

site support

Poorva Express: हुगली सी बहती तेरी चाल है पूर्वा तू बेमिसाल है - Keshav Singh

Search Forum
<<prev entry    next entry>>
Blog Entry# 3300038
Posted: Apr 14 2018 (00:46)

4 Responses
Last Response: May 06 2018 (20:39)
Poll
13256 views
23 votes
1

Apr 14 2018 (00:46)  
Dhanno
Dhanno   3041 blog posts
Entry# 3300038               Past Edits
A poll to get your opinion on a new change I noticed.
.
The "Rating Score" has now included TL count too.
.
My questions:
1.
...
more...
Shouldn't TL be in the separate TL header? Why bring its score under Forum score?
2. If total conf TL is added, then shouldn't the 'total Green Flags of IMG trains' be added to the "Rating Score"?
3. If total conf TL is added, then shouldn't the total PNR predictions be added to the "Rating Score"?
4. If total conf TL is added, then shouldn't the 'total vigilance score' be added to the "Rating Score"?
5. If total conf TL is added, then shouldn't the total votes garnered from the polls conducted be added to the "Rating Score"?
.
Because if "Rating Score" reflects total effort of the member (by adding conf TLs), then I believe other efforts of the member too should be added.
.

Translate to English
Translate to Hindi
NO vote
Yes. Everything should be added.
9%
2
Yes. Some of them should be added. .... in comments reply.
0%
0
No. Let it be restored to the way it was previously.
78%
18
This new score is ok.
13%
3

2 Public Posts - Sat Apr 14, 2018

7230 views
1

Apr 14 2018 (16:35)
Arun   1967 blog posts
Re# 3300038-3               Past Edits
1. "contradictorily" - yes, there are members (some) in this forum who simply don't update wrong loco details. They just update correct and known information.
And there are members who painstakingly do updates of inaugural trains which again someone updates a wrong date and stamps it themselves.
Now I can go on and name names, but a perusal of my recent comments will show you what I am speaking about. And that's just to give an example.
And
...
more...
there are so many examples that I and many members can give.
.
2. Voided? Really? When I posted this comment, I told - "Just look at the TL right now - loco links are given even before train gets E-Loco change." The trains which still haven't got E-Loco have been updated with E-Locos from many sheds.
Full discussion ? Full discussion is a myth. We saw how a TLM who questioned an Admin for wrong Atlas updates and finally gave up. Imagine a member arguing against an Admin or TLM. And would you intervene and question that Admin or TLM? No you conveniently blame us who question the wrong TL. The wrong updater becomes the victim and we the members who question, become the culprit.
Ex. from your statement:
"Pl. note that ALL member updates are highly appreciated on this site. We just cannot have rudeness and dis-harmony here. Above all, members' seniority and past participation in this site is most respected, and we do not allow their reputation to be tarnished because of one update or the other. Although this site is about rail info, we value human dignity above railway updates."
.
No question of yanking the power off these false updaters/stampers and so they continue in their merry way. And when you portray us a villains, then who will question false updates?
FMs used to question these guys and now conveniently with you putting the onus on others, no one will question.
.
3. "PF updates currently have the same weight as TT update." ---- Really? So many times you said TT updation is the most important.
I think - PF updation is basically an add-on like - if a small station has just 1 or 2 PFs, so convenient to update all trains that halt there. And now you are equating TT to PF updation?
.
Here's you saying:
/blog/post/2095722
"The reason for this is that some kinds of updates require more hard work and are more useful than others."
"So, for instance, TT updates, Train News (Latest) will have up to 3X the number of points for Train Name updates."
Now you are contradicting yourself. You value TT updation around 3 times more and now you are equating that to PF updation!!!?
.
Leaving alone what you said, I am sure there are many members who will contradict you that TT updation is valued more and difficult than PF updation.
.

Translate to English
Translate to Hindi

1 Public Posts - Sun May 06, 2018
Scroll to Top
Scroll to Bottom
Go to Desktop site
Important Note: This website NEVER solicits for Money or Donations. Please beware of anyone requesting/demanding money on behalf of IRI. Thanks.
Disclaimer: This website has NO affiliation with the Government-run site of Indian Railways. This site does NOT claim 100% accuracy of fast-changing Rail Information. YOU are responsible for independently confirming the validity of information through other sources.
India Rail Info Privacy Policy