Start RailFanning NOW, learn to live - before you run out of time - Varun

Greetings,
I would like to share how allotment was made under HO quota in SL class of 12173 on 11.11.2012.It will give you lot of surprises.
Designation of person/office whose recommendation were accepted:
CRB,
...
more...

MR,
SEC WR,
PSI DRM
PSII DRM
CPO
Sr.DCM
Gen Sec NRMU
SCM (HQ)
CPRO
SR.SM CSTM
DY.CSTM NE
Designation of person whose application were rejected.
DCTI CSTM
AOM/KRCL
CMM-M
ADD SEC SC/ST EMP UNION
ATM-GOODS
STM-GOODS
DIV.SEC-CRMS
DCM-GOODS
DRM-BCT
STM-GOODS
PA to Minister for Public Work
Anand Pranjpe MP
ADM CISF
Hinductan Chamber Of commerce
Eknath Gaikwad-MP
DYCCM PS
Member DRUCC
CPO
Sr.DOM
My queries are as follows.
1)Why the recommendation made by Minister & 2 MPs were rejected?It is generally assume that MP/Minister letter is sure shot in getting HO quota released.
2)SR.DCM recommendation was accepted but CMM recommendation was rejected,Why?
3)DY.CTM NE recommendation was accepted but DYCCM-PS recommendation was rejected,Why?
I request the members who have knowledge regarding above issue to kindly solve this mystery for me.
With Regards
Adil Nomani